Berliner Tageszeitung - Scarlett Johansson faces tough reviews in director debut

Actors heading behind the camera is something of a trend in Cannes this year, with "Twilight" star Kristen Stewart and British actor Harris Dickinson both showcasing their first features.

Johansson appears to have found the transition more difficult than her contemporaries, with critics' views on "Eleanor the Great" likely to make difficult reading for one of Hollywood's most bankable stars.

Film bible Variety called it "an unconvincing crowd-pleaser", while The Hollywood Reporter said it was "wobbly" and "a sentimental Holocaust weeper".

While the New York-born star "does a perfectly efficient job of directing, (she) doesn't hone the tone of her scenes", Variety said.

Lead actress June Squibb, 95, won praise for her turn as a grief-stricken retiree who moves to New York and adopts the personal story of her deceased best friend who survived the Holocaust.

"It's a film about many things: it's about friendship, it's about grief, it's about forgiveness. And I think those are all themes that we can use a lot more of these days," Johansson said after the premiere.

- In competition -

Johansson's movie is in the running for prizes in the "Certain Regard" secondary section at Cannes for up-and-coming directors that also includes Stewart's and Dickinson's films this year.

Dickinson, the 28-year-old star of "Babygirl", asked the press to be "gentle" as he unveiled "Urchin", a touching film about a rough sleeper in London.

"It's my first film so if you don't like it, break it to me nicely," he said before the premiere on Saturday.

Initial reviews have been positive, with his social-realist debut said to have echoes of the work of veteran British director Mike Leigh, a past winner of Cannes' top prize.

Actors generally have a spotty record when it comes to directing, with Oscar-winning Clint Eastwood one of a small band to have convinced when calling the shots on set.

Greta Gerwig, who broke through as an actress before hitting the directorial big time with 2023 hit "Barbie", has also clocked up a string of hits.

Australian screen great Nicole Kidman lamented on Sunday how the number of women directing major box office successes is still "incredibly low".

Stewart might be one to watch for the future, judging by the rapturous reception to her debut, "The Chronology of Water", a searing examination of child sex abuse.

Rolling Stone magazine said the 35-year-old has "accomplished what she set out to do, with honors".

D. Fjodorow--BTZ